Do you think Heathcliff loved Hareton, — Wuthering Q&A
time to discover the relationships among the occupants of the house: a young Meanwhile, Heathcliff is staying at Wuthering Heights with Hindley Earnshaw, .. novel is how much we trust the perceptions of the narrators, Lockwood and Nelly. Wuthering Heights tells the story of Heathcliff and his passive relationships with the two establishing a kind of trust between them and the reader. The novelist . Hareton relationship with a new kind of emphasis (Miriam Allott, "Wuthering. Alexandra Hawes Perhaps Heathcliff saw a somewhat resemblance between himself and Catherine's, and Hareton and Cathy's relationships. As both Heathcliff.
Catherine eventually strays too far on the moor and encounters the residents of Wuthering Heights.
Heathcliff begins his scheme of marrying Catherine to Linton, so that he will inherit Thrushcross Grange when Edgarwho is ill and dying, and Linton, who is also ill and dying, eventually pass on. Catherine forms a deep attachment to Linton when they first meet and they carry on a forbidden affair for some time.
Wuthering Heights | BritLit
In the book and some movie versions she had met him once already, when his uncle tried to take custody of him. But because everyone is so sick, Heathcliff must act. He kidnaps Catherine and forces her to marry Linton. So she is rude to him, and he is rude to her in return.
Catherine and Hareton in Wuthering Heights Everyone mistreats each other in the atmosphere of hate that Heathcliff has created, however there is a strange bond between Hareton and Heathcliff: Heathcliff likes him a lot more than he did his own son.
This drives another wedge in between Catherine and Hareton. However, her loneliness and boredom eventually lead her to befriend him and their natural affinity for each other is rekindled.
He enters a renewed state of mourning over Cathy and wastes away and dies.
Before the story concludes, we find out that Hareton and Catherine are going to marry and live at Thrushcross Grange. Catherine has taught Hareton how to read and not be so much down in the mud where Heathcliff wanted him, and they are very happy.
As you can see, Catherine and Hareton represent a sort of redemption of all of the characters, the bad cycles, the bad choices. In the book the characters are quite young. Cathy is 16 when Edgar proposes marriage, and all four of them are roughly the same age, with Hindley and Nelly being a few years older. Likewise Catherine is 16 when she marries Linton. Though some of that comes from wanting to only use 2 actors for each character — child and grown.
One major difference between the novels and the movies is how the story is told. The novel is from the point of view of Mr. Lockwood, a tenant who comes to live at Thrushcross Grange after Heathcliff lets it following the deaths of Linton and Edgar.
Lockwood makes a neighborly visit to Wuthering Heights to meet his landlord, and also encounters Catherine and Hareton while he is there. He reads some of her diary, and after observing the odd behavior of the inhabitants there, he implores Nelly, who is now housekeeper at Thrushcross Grange, to recount their story.
So the meat of the story is narrated by Nelly. So, as you can see, the novel is told from the perspective of someone observing what is happening, not by its participants.
And, as you can imagine, Nelly is an extremely important character in the book, since most of what we know is what she has chosen to tell us, and is through the lens of how she viewed things. Understandably, she plays a much less significant role in the movies, and yet it never quite feels fair.
It was authored by an English professor, Alison Case, who has been teaching Wuthering Heights for years. I thought it was very good, if a bit long. I also thought it was great justice for Nelly, who really has no life of her own in the original novel outside of the drama of these people she works for.
It was nice to get to see her be the heroine and to fill out her motivations and thoughts. And in Wuthering Heights where we got to hear hints of strong feeling or where you would imagine there would have been a lot of pain for Nelly, Nelly Dean really goes for the gut.
Nelly was given Hareton to raise, and for five years she raised him, until Cathy took Nelly with her to Thrushcross Grange when she married. Alison Case really delves into that kind of stuff. Nelly Dean has several aspects that are interesting for our purposes. She raised Hareton until he was 5, and raised Catherine her entire life. As a child he was very afraid of Hindley, which made him more timid.
Hindley was always cold hearted and judgemental, even as a child. This was only made worse when his beloved wife died, and his treatment of his son, who reminded him of said deceased wife, reflected that. When Hindley wasn't ignoring the fact that he had a son, he was terrifying him. Nelly was Hareton's appointed caregiver in his very young years, she recounted, "He attempted to touch the child, who In parenthood, Hindley was a mean and careless person. Then, when Heathcliff became a bigger part of his life, and a father figure to him, he became violent, aggressive and impolite because of Heathcliff's influence.Catherine + Heathcliff -- haunt me [wuthering heights]
This, of course, further proves that Heathcliff's character was all of the above characteristics, and hateful, as he took his revenge on Hindley by mistreating his son, Hareton. Heathcliff acknowledges his mistreatment of Hareton and the fact that he's only doing it to get revenge on his father, by saying, "I'd have loved the lad had he been someone else. I've got him faster than his scoundrel of a father secured me, and lower Edgar's parenting was very strict, but also full of love and kindness for his daughter.
Nevertheless, Heathcliff's impulsive paternal instincts towards Hareton are revealed when, during one fraught episode in which Hindley's alcoholism takes him too far, he saves the infant from a potentially fatal fall from the top of the Heights' staircase.
Because of the dark, savage environment in which he grows up, the boy becomes an ignorant, dirty and uneducated man, unable to read or write. When Cathy Linton comes to Wuthering Heights sixteen years later, Hareton has not changed, but it is apparent that he sees Heathcliff as his own father and loves him dearly.
Heathcliff has a secret regard for Hareton as well, but he wishes him to feel the same pain that he himself experienced in childhood. Hareton forms an attraction to Cathy, but she dismisses it with disgust, insisting that he is a mindless, rude beast of a man. This only continues after Cathy's husband, Linton Heathcliff, dies, and Cathy becomes accustomed to the terror of Wuthering Heights. She grows just as rude and cold as its inhabitants, and, whenever Hareton expresses any amount of regard or tenderness towards her, she spurns it.
Cathy and Hareton's relationship changes when, eventually, Cathy decides to help him with his secret self-education by teaching him how to read and talk properly.